Blitz on human rights 'nonsense'
Source: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/6345477.stm
Quote:
Blitz on human rights 'nonsense'
A more "common sense" approach to human rights laws is needed by public bodies who sometimes misinterpret them, the Lord Chancellor is to say.
In a speech later Lord Falconer will say the importance of the Human Rights Act has been "clouded by nonsense".
The Tories have said they would scrap the Act altogether claiming it is being abused by criminals.
But Lord Falconer will say that if rulings do not make common sense, then the Act has been wrongly interpreted.
He will give a speech at Manchester University, to set out a campaign to explain the Act to public rights workers.
It follows several reports of cases, where the rights of criminals appear to have been put above public safety.
These include a convicted paedophile being allowed to use a gym shared by school pupils and a suspected car thief who was served fried chicken during a 20-hour siege.
Lord Falconer told the BBC that was "absolute nonsense".
Reporting errors
"Common sense would tell you you are not entitled to food if you are running away from the police. You are not entitled to not have your photograph shown if you are a convicted murderer on the run."
He added: "What we are trying to do is to bust these myths".
In some cases press reporting incorrectly attributed decisions to human rights legislation he said.
But he admitted: "There have been problems with how human rights and the Human Rights Act have been interpreted."
Ministers have also been warned to stop using the act as a "convenient scapegoat" for government failings, by the Commons joint select committee on human rights.
And David Heath MP, for the Liberal Democrats, said: "It is unfortunate that it has taken so long for government ministers to defend their flagship legislation.
"Indeed, sometimes they seem to have led ill-informed criticism, rather than rebutted it."
Conservative leader David Cameron has said he wants the Human Rights Act to be replaced with a British Bill of Rights to protect UK citizens.
Prime Minister Tony Blair condemned a High Court ruling returning nine asylum seekers who hijacked a plane at Stansted, to Afghanistan as an abuse of common sense.
There were reports of plans to make sweeping changes to human rights laws last year - but a government review recommended that new guidance should be given on interpreting the Act instead.
Lord Falconer's department will work with staff in "frontline services", like education, probation and the police, to make sure the laws are being interpreted correctly.
A handbook explaining key human rights principles for public officials has also been produced.
|
Extract:
Quote:
|
"Common sense would tell you you are not entitled to food if you are running away from the police. You are not entitled to not have your photograph shown if you are a convicted murderer on the run."
|
Since when has this government been about common sense? Is this 'guidance' really going to stop the absurdity that this Act causes?
Will Labour also now rid of the Occupier's liability Act, which places a duty of care on homeowners for trespassers and burglars. :x
__________________
Manus haec inimica tyrannis ense petit placidam sub libertate quietam - "This hand of mine, which is hostile to tyrants, seeks by the sword quiet peace under liberty."
|
09-02-2007, 03:13 PM
Linear Mode
