Do you need to have a clear English identity before an effective English Parliament?

[race_inspector]

Do you all need to have a clear English identity before you all can have an effective English Parliament?

Unfinished Business?

http://www.democracyforum.co.uk/vogo...english-4.html

http://www.democracyforum.co.uk/engl...m-english.html

[Mr Rob]

No such condition was a prerequisite for the establishment of the Scottish Parliament or the Welsh Assembly.............and as for Stormont.......

[alycidond9009]

Well, as we all know, Northern Eireland is full of Scots'.

[Mr Rob]

Well, as we all know, Northern Eireland is full of Scots'.

Full of Scots' what?

[race_inspector]

No such condition was a prerequisite for the establishment of the Scottish Parliament or the Welsh Assembly.............and as for Stormont.......

Establishment Prerequisites

How has the fact that "no such condition was a prerequisite for the establishment of the Scottish Parliament or the Welsh Assembly" impacted the quality of the decision making processes in those organisations?


Think carefully.

Answer intelligently.

What say ye? (What say you all?)








Answer:

Join the BritDems or else . . .

[Mr Rob]

Establishment Prerequisites

How has the fact that "no such condition was a prerequisite for the establishment of the Scottish Parliament or the Welsh Assembly" impacted the quality of the decision making processes in those organisations?


Think carefully.

Answer intelligently.

What say ye? (What say you all?)

The decision making processes are procedural and their quality is independent of the any consideration of ethnic identity.

If you mean the quality of the decisions themselves, then I would suggest that any noticeable improvement in any of our representative bodies could only be achieved with the aid of piano wire, lamposts and machetes.

It is still desirable for those who propose, draft and vote on issues affecting constituencies in England to be answerable to constituencies in England.

[race_inspector]

The decision making processes are procedural and their quality is independent of the any consideration of ethnic identity.

That statement sounds impressive.

Is it true?

Please expound.

[Mr Rob]

That statement sounds impressive.

Is it true?

Please expound.

I am glad you were impressed.

It would be like saying that the criterion for relegation from the Premier League is ethnically dependent.

You could, of course, say it, but it might lack power and clarity.

[race_inspector]

I am glad you were impressed.

It would be like saying that the criterion for relegation from the Premier League is ethnically dependent.

You could, of course, say it, but it might lack power and clarity.

Are you saying that ethnicity cannot and does not impact decision making processes?

Think carefully.

Answer intelligently.

What sayest thou? (What say you?)

[alycidond9009]

Well, as we all know, Northern Eireland is full of Scots'.

Scots' not scot's.